25 Nov
2003
25 Nov
'03
4:56 a.m.
Jiri Kuthan wrote:
that's not related to 8.12, that's related to
your script
which drops ACK on the floor.
Yikes...your right.
If you introduced stateful
processing using t_relay for INVITE, ACK must be treated
the same way. If you drop the ACKs instead, transaction
processing will keep sending negative replies till it
gives up.
ACK is a completely separate transaction?
Changing the condition for INVITE to (method=="INVITE" ||
method=="ACK") should fix it. For negative replies,
request-uri must be same as for INVITEs and ACKs will follow
the same script processing path. Eventually, it will
hit t_relay, which will stop retransmitting 487.
BTW: BYE special-casing should normally not occur as all BYEs
should normaly be processed by loose_route.
Got it.
Thanks, all clean again!
---greg
-jiri
At 08:16 PM 11/22/2003, Greg Fausak wrote:
I just loaded the 0.8.12 server on my lab linux
9.x box.
Running postgres/2 current registrations, 123456(a)named.com
and 9723937976(a)named.com. My configuration allows calls
between these two no problem. I can hangup from either
end with no problem. I am seeing a problem with a CANCEL
message. If one end calls the other, and than CANCELs the
communication before the other end ACKs, I get several messages
CANCEL
ACK
CANCEL
ACK
...
I read the serusers list and see that Maxim and Andrea reported
the same problem. I don't see the problem in my production
configuration on 0.8.11. What can I do to make the CANCEL work?
Here is my configuration:
UA1 XTEN XPRO
UA2 Cisco 7960
SER 0.8.12 configuration:
-------------start---------------
route{
# initial sanity checks -- messages with
# max_forwards==0, or excessively long requests
if (!mf_process_maxfwd_header("10")) {
sl_send_reply("483","Too Many Hops");
break;
};
if (msg:len >= max_len ) {
sl_send_reply("513", "Message too big");
break;
};
# we record-route all messages -- to make sure that
# subsequent messages will go through our proxy; that's
# particularly good if upstream and downstream entities
# use different transport protocol
if (!method=="REGISTER") record_route();
# subsequent messages withing a dialog should take the
# path determined by record-routing
if (loose_route()) {
# mark routing logic in request
append_hf("P-hint: rr-enforced\r\n");
xlog("L_WARN", "LOOSE: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci contact:%ct
from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru messageid:%mi\n");
setflag(1);
setflag(2);
route(1);
break;
};
if (!uri==myself) {
# mark routing logic in request
append_hf("P-hint: outbound\r\n");
route(1);
break;
};
# if the request is for other domain use UsrLoc
# (in case, it does not work, use the following command
# with proper names and addresses in it)
if (uri==myself) {
if (method=="REGISTER") {
if (!www_authorize("named.com", "subscriber"))
{
www_challenge("named.com", "0");
break;
};
save("location");
break;
};
lookup("aliases");
if (!uri==myself) {
append_hf("P-hint: outbound alias\r\n");
route(1);
break;
};
if (method=="INVITE") {
if (!www_authorize("named.com", "subscriber"))
{
www_challenge("named.com", "0");
break;
};
xlog("L_WARN", "INVITE: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci
contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
#
if (lookup("location")) {
route(1);
break;
};
if(uri=~"sip:[0-9]{10}@.*")
{
xlog("L_WARN", "10DIGIT: %Ts call-id:%ci
cseq:%ci contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
route(2);
break;
}
xlog("L_WARN", "UNKNOWN: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci
contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
sl_send_reply("580", "Sorry");
break;
};
if (method=="CANCEL") {
xlog("L_WARN", "CANCEL: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci
contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
route(2);
break;
};
if (method=="BYE") {
xlog("L_WARN", "BYE: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci
contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
route(2);
break;
};
if (method=="ACK") {
xlog("L_WARN", "ACK: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci
contact:%ct from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru
messageid:%mi\n");
break;
};
sl_send_reply("404", "Not Found");
break;
};
xlog("L_WARN", "FAILATBOTTOM: %Ts call-id:%ci cseq:%ci contact:%ct
from:%fu fromtag:%ft to:%tu totag:%tt method:%rm ruri:%ru messageid:%mi\n");
break;
}
route[1]
{
# send it out now; use stateful forwarding as it works reliably
# even for UDP2TCP
if (!t_relay()) {
sl_reply_error();
};
}
route[2]
{
consume_credentials();
rewritehostport("1.2.3.4:5060");
if(!t_relay()) {
sl_reply_error();
break;
};
}
--------------------
here are the ngrep packets, from invite to duplicate CANCEL packets...
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:32.356665 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.218:5060
INVITE sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060 SIP/2.0.
Max-Forwards: 10.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>.
Contact: <sip:123456@66.228.53.216:5060>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Authorization: Digest
username="123456",realm="named.com",nonce="3fbfb5d42576afa9e9384c4f0f16427e46909d1d",response="7bf9fe190978d98811d56ddb60dded2f",uri="sip:9723937976@named.com".
Content-Type: application/sdp.
User-Agent: X-PRO build 1050.
Content-Length: 322.
.
v=0.
o=123456 485850365 485850365 IN IP4 66.228.53.216.
s=X-PRO.
c=IN IP4 66.228.53.216.
t=0 0.
m=audio 8000 RTP/AVP 0 8 3 4 98 97 101.
a=rtpmap:0 pcmu/8000.
a=rtpmap:8 pcma/8000.
a=rtpmap:3 gsm/8000.
a=rtpmap:4 G723/8000.
a=rtpmap:98 iLBC/8000.
a=rtpmap:97 speex/8000.
a=rtpmap:101 telephone-event/8000.
a=fmtp:101 0-15.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:32.619424 66.228.53.218:50560 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
SIP/2.0 100 Trying.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0,SIP/2.0/UDP
66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: CSCO/5.
Contact: <sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060>.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:32.728062 66.228.53.218:50561 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
SIP/2.0 180 Ringing.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0,SIP/2.0/UDP
66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=000b5faab82400151dddd662-025452b6.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: CSCO/5.
Contact: <sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060>.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:32.728480 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.216:5060
SIP/2.0 180 Ringing.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=000b5faab82400151dddd662-025452b6.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: CSCO/5.
Contact: <sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060>.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.846506 66.228.53.216:5060 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
CANCEL sip:9723937976@named.com SIP/2.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>.
Contact: <sip:123456@66.228.53.216:5060>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 CANCEL.
User-Agent: X-PRO build 1050.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.847662 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.218:5060
CANCEL sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060 SIP/2.0.
Max-Forwards: 10.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>.
Contact: <sip:123456@66.228.53.216:5060>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 CANCEL.
User-Agent: X-PRO build 1050.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.847761 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.216:5060
SIP/2.0 200 cancelling.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=a6a1c5f60faecf035a1ae5b6e96e979a-6763.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 CANCEL.
Server: Sip EXpress router (0.8.12 (i386/linux)).
Content-Length: 0.
Warning: 392 66.228.44.254:5060 "Noisy feedback tells: pid=10695
req_src_ip=66.228.53.216 req_src_port=5060 in_uri=sip:9723937976@named.com
out_uri=sip:9723937976@65.77.154.243:5060 via_cnt==1".
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.847806 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.216:5060
SIP/2.0 487 Request cancelled.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=a6a1c5f60faecf035a1ae5b6e96e979a-6763.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: Sip EXpress router (0.8.12 (i386/linux)).
Content-Length: 0.
Warning: 392 66.228.44.254:5060 "Noisy feedback tells: pid=10695
req_src_ip=66.228.53.216 req_src_port=5060 in_uri=sip:9723937976@named.com
out_uri=sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060 via_cnt==1".
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.875833 66.228.53.216:5060 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
ACK sip:9723937976@named.com SIP/2.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=a6a1c5f60faecf035a1ae5b6e96e979a-6763.
Contact: <sip:123456@66.228.53.216:5060>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 ACK.
Max-Forwards: 70.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.906960 66.228.53.218:50562 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
SIP/2.0 200 OK.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0,SIP/2.0/UDP
66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=000b5faab82400151dddd662-025452b6.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 CANCEL.
Server: CSCO/5.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.942865 66.228.53.218:50563 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
SIP/2.0 487 Request Cancelled.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0,SIP/2.0/UDP
66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=000b5faab82400151dddd662-025452b6.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: CSCO/5.
Contact: <sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060>.
Record-Route: <sip:9723937976@66.228.44.254;ftag=320951244;lr>.
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:34.943103 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.218:5060
ACK sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060 SIP/2.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.44.254;branch=z9hG4bKe198.142630c1.0.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=000b5faab82400151dddd662-025452b6.
CSeq: 19721 ACK.
User-Agent: Sip EXpress router(0.8.12 (i386/linux)).
Content-Length: 0.
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:35.649964 66.228.44.254:5060 -> 66.228.53.216:5060
SIP/2.0 487 Request cancelled.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=a6a1c5f60faecf035a1ae5b6e96e979a-6763.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 INVITE.
Server: Sip EXpress router (0.8.12 (i386/linux)).
Content-Length: 0.
Warning: 392 66.228.44.254:5060 "Noisy feedback tells: pid=10695
req_src_ip=66.228.53.216 req_src_port=5060 in_uri=sip:9723937976@named.com
out_uri=sip:9723937976@66.228.53.218:5060 via_cnt==1".
.
#
U 2003/11/22 13:10:35.671936 66.228.53.216:5060 -> 66.228.44.254:5060
ACK sip:9723937976@named.com SIP/2.0.
Via: SIP/2.0/UDP 66.228.53.216:5060.
From: 123456 <sip:123456@named.com>;tag=320951244.
To: <sip:9723937976@named.com>;tag=a6a1c5f60faecf035a1ae5b6e96e979a-6763.
Contact: <sip:123456@66.228.53.216:5060>.
Call-ID: A7A5E0C3-865F-41A1-9CAD-EE1B104D7244(a)66.228.53.216.
CSeq: 19721 ACK.
Max-Forwards: 70.
Content-Length: 0.
.
The 487CANCEL/ACK/CANCEL/ACK/CANCEL/ACK goes on and on until
something eventually times out. Anybody have any ideas? The CANCEL
works, but the excess chatter isn't wanted.
Thanks,
---greg
_______________________________________________
Serusers mailing list
serusers(a)lists.iptel.org
http://lists.iptel.org/mailman/listinfo/serusers
--
Jiri Kuthan http://iptel.org/~jiri/