Re: [Serusers] What's the best solutions ? RTP Proxy or STUN Server ?

Jiri Kuthan wrote: You can't choose between the fruit basket and an apple... STUN checks the NAT situation from a client point of view. STUN does not do magic to let your calls through, it gives the UA an idea on how the world looks and then the UA makes the choice on how to get traffic going or give up and eat up all the fruits in the basket. If you have problems with your NAT, the RTP proxy might be part of the solution to get calls going in combination with SER module Nathelper. The whole idea is to take care of the media stream when the two SIP clients can't handle the media stream across the NAT's. Yes, it shouldn't be necessary. Other solutions involve symmetric RTP, see http://www.voip-info.org/wiki-RTP+Symmetric More info on STUN: http://www.voip-info.org/tiki-index.php?page=Stun Vovida.org have an Open Source STUN server. Pointer here: http://www.voip-info.org/tiki-index.php?page=Open%20Source%20Voip%20software Disclaimer: This is a messy area. I could be all wrong... :-) /Olle