Regarding the business rule, can you explain more about
YOu can specify max contacts on the registration of an endpoint
For instance, how and where is the max contacts specified?
There still might be an issue, as it is pointless to store multiple registrations for a single user-agent that re-regisers (without un-registering) using the same IP address, like below: bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49569;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:26:360.50 bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49584;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:33:250.50 bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49585;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:35:330.50 bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49586;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:37:430.50 bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49587;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:39:510.50 bluesip/user,sip:pb@86.8.210.156:49588;rinstance=991CCEE9;transport=tcp2010-12-22 01:42:000.50
Only the last line is the active one. The first five registrations are old and overridden by the newer registration. For instance: ports 49569, 49584, 49585, 49586 and 49587 are no longer in the NAT routing table, only 49588 is.
Op 22 dec 2010, om 01:03 heeft David J. het volgende geschreven:
Its not an issue;
AG Projects may allow multiple registrations from the SAME IP whereas the other company may not;
Thats a business rule; Not a bug; YOu can specify max contacts on the registration of an endpoint.
Its not a bug.
On 12/21/10 6:58 PM, cerieljacobs wrote:
Bluesip.net uses "Sip EXpress router (0.9.7 (i386/linux))" and on client registration it returns "SIP/2.0 403 Max Registrations per IP exceeded" due to some bug/error/failure in the version 1.4 Acrobits Business softphone user-agent to unregister correctly.
Strange is that this never happens with accounts on AG Projects, "OpenSIPS (1.4.5-notls (x86_64/linux))" server. This server software seems to remove old registrations for the same user-agent from the same ip address.
What should be changed in Sip EXpress router, to store only one single registration per user-agent/IP combination?
Thanks,Ceriel _______________________________________________ SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list sr-users@lists.sip-router.org http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users
-
cerieljacobs